Skull And Bones: Accessibility Review

Disclaimer

The copy of the game used for this review was provided by the publisher at no cost to the reviewer.

Introduction

Skull And Bones. A name synonymous with languishing development, spiralling costs and ever shifting ideas of what the title should be. Now, many years on from its original and several other planned release dates, this multi-platform sea-based adventure is finally out in the wild.

Thanks to a review code, we get to look at the usual big question: Just how accessible is this pirate game without sight?

Note

The information presented in this review is accurate as of the game’s launch and the first fortnight after its release, please be aware that things may change over time.

First Boot

On first boot, we’re greeted by logos and what I would guess is a title screen, though no narration appears here. Pressing A (as I’m playing on Xbox), initially nothing seems to have changed regarding the reading of menus, but after waiting a while, a prompt is voiced that indicates we’re on the narration option and that it’s toggled to off.

Pressing A on this enables narration and, from here, the rest of the setup process can be completed without assistance.

Unfortunately, not everything reads (such as the menu languages in that particular submenu), though for the most part it’s very straightforward.

Also as a frustrating note, the pirate code/code of conduct gets cut off before it can be fully read, saying “I will keep co… B button Back”, meaning you don’t actually get to read it all.

Hitting I agree then launch, you get transferred into the main menu.

The Game Itself

With the aethereal yet sinister score continuing, I was actually greeted by a non-narrated prompt, because I’d earned some additional items as part of my review copy. Thankfully, the A button dismisses any further similar prompts, with B closing this UI flow. When I had similar items appear later down the line, this style of prompt was narrated, though again this was not the case at launch.

Once that’s dealt with, you now get a narrated, DPad navigable menu system.

After customising settings to my liking, though finding no navigational assists or aim-related adjustments I could make to potentially make the game more accessible without sighted assistance, I clicked play.

Setting Sail

Once I’d watched a cutscene which had no audio description, a forceful voice greeted me, followed by a conversation. This done, a tutorial was narrated telling me to use the left stick to steer. Unfortunately, with no way of knowing where to go, it’s easy to get turned around, pun most definitely intended.

Following the sounds of the waves so that they were in the centre, I eventually was informed, after some more dialogue, to hold left trigger to aim and right trigger to fire. Whether this is an intended navigation method, I’m not sure, but I kept it in mind for future investigation.

After a good while of attacking (and presumably being hit by) other rival ships, not really having a sense of the ranges between combatants but knowing their direction from their own audio cues, you eventually discover this sequence is all a contrivance of sorts, scripted to sink you anyway.

Once you awaken, however, you have no sense of where to go, what to do or how to progress in general. This is, in fact, because you’re in an avatar/pirate creator. At this point, I initially put the game down as the opening sequence had taken a significant chunk of time, though I am uncertain as to how long this would take a sighted player by comparison.

Diving back into the pirate creator at a later point in time, I discovered that you won’t get any prompts until you press A, at which point narration will kick back in and give you info on the controls. Unfortunately this still doesn’t improve the accessibility in terms of actually customising your pirate, with arguably your best option being to just press menu to continue onwards. This is because the options you’re moving through are not narrated, meaning that you have no sense of what you’re changing.

Pressing A to confirm that you are “ready to rule the seas”, you are entered into a cutscene and a conversation. Having to steer, you are not informed where your destination is in relation to you in terms of accessible information, but you do eventually get a prompt as to how to gain additional speed using what is called crew stamina. This crew stamina is not something you can check via accessible means, but appeared to just refresh over time.

Remember that navigation strategy I referenced earlier, centering sounds that I thought would take me toward my objective? I tried this again and here, surprisingly, it seemed to work for a second time. After following the loudest waves and wind cues, I somehow managed to get onto an island, with prompts advising me when I could disembark, though I still didn’t feel like I had a true sense of an objective or direction.

After wandering around for a little while and though I could pick up a few items on the island, I could not seem to progress and thus put the game down again, feeling like I’d got somewhere but nowhere near the full potential of the open world. I may return to this game on stream with sighted assistance at a later time.

Keep in mind that this was all without any assistance, more through luck than judgement, but it did show the potential of in-universe sounds being usable as a navigation beacon.

Summary

Pros

  • Menu and UI narration available which seems to be being updated over time
  • Score and sound design are solid

Cons

  • Game does not have enough accessibility for coherent navigation or aiming without trial and error or sighted assistance

Conclusions

Considering how long Skull And Bones was in development, I was not necessarily expecting much in terms of accessibility, even with this being a Ubisoft game where that across varying levels of vision has been a major factor in their releases for a while. However, though I couldn’t play much of the game, it feels like something that could, given time, be made more accessible to gamers without sight.

Would I recommend it to those without sighted assistance? Not at the moment. But the fact that narration is in here at all given its 10+ years of troubled construction is a sign, to me, that this could be at least somewhat playable in the future if navigational indicators were added as well as other elements.

If nothing else, I’m proud of the team for managing to implement this and numerous other accessibility options, particularly given that this is a multi-player title where accessibility is sometimes seen as difficult to balance or to implement at all. I look forward to seeing this game evolve as time goes on and I’ll be interested to see what else is added in the future.

Back to the main reviews, guides and articles page